Grand Island, NY — A devastating boating accident on the Upper Niagara River has left two Western New York communities heartbroken, following the deaths of 46-year-old Natalie Sansivero of Grand Island and 66-year-old Jerome Williams of Buffalo. The tragic incident occurred late Tuesday evening, July 23, when their boat struck a concrete abutment near Navy Island, ejecting both individuals into the fast-moving water.
The Accident
According to the New York State Park Police, Niagara County 911 received an emergency call at approximately 9:40 p.m. reporting a serious boating crash and two missing persons. The vessel, a small recreational boat, had collided with a fixed structure in the river and was found heavily damaged. The impact of the crash threw both Natalie and Jerome into the water.
Massive Multi-Agency Search Operation
Emergency responders quickly mobilized, launching an extensive search and rescue operation that continued into the early morning hours. Agencies involved included:
- New York State Park Police
- United States Coast Guard
- Niagara and Erie County Sheriff’s Offices
- Grand Island Fire Company
- Town and City of Tonawanda Police
- Erie County Air 1
- River Road Fire Department
- North Tonawanda Professional Firefighters Local 1333
- Niagara County and City of Tonawanda Marine Units
Despite their exhaustive efforts, the victims were not found during the overnight search. The operation was temporarily suspended at 3:00 a.m. due to low visibility and resumed at sunrise on Wednesday.
Ongoing Investigation
The damaged vessel was recovered from the water and is now under examination by investigators with the New York State Police Bureau of Criminal Investigation (BCI), who are working to reconstruct the accident. Officials are urging anyone with knowledge of the vessel’s movements or who may have witnessed the crash to come forward. Tips can be directed to State Park Police Niagara Headquarters at (716) 278-1777.
Remembering the Victims
The victims of this heartbreaking tragedy have been identified and remembered with deep affection by their communities:
- Natalie Sansivero, 46, was a beloved resident of Grand Island, known for her vibrant spirit, compassion, and commitment to her family and community. Those who knew her speak of her warm personality, infectious laughter, and the care she showed everyone around her.
- Jerome Williams, 66, of Buffalo, was cherished for his wisdom, humility, and lifelong love for nature and the outdoors. A guiding figure to his loved ones, Jerome was respected by all who crossed his path.
Together, Natalie and Jerome were enjoying what was meant to be a peaceful night on the water — a poignant reminder of how fragile and unpredictable life can be.
Community in Mourning
The loss has reverberated across Grand Island and Buffalo. Vigils and tributes are being planned, and an outpouring of grief and remembrance has flooded social media as friends and loved ones grapple with the enormity of this tragedy.
“This is a heartbreaking loss,” said one Grand Island neighbor. “Natalie and Jerome were both bright lights in our community. It’s difficult to process that they’re gone.”
Local leaders have expressed condolences and reminded the public of the need for caution and responsibility on waterways, especially after dark.
A Wake-Up Call for Boating Safety
In the wake of the accident, authorities are emphasizing vital safety practices for those enjoying the region’s rivers and lakes:
- Avoid boating after dark when visibility is reduced
- Always wear a properly fitted life jacket
- Operate vessels at safe speeds, especially in unfamiliar waters
- Keep emergency signaling devices on board
- Stay vigilant for submerged or fixed obstacles
Officials hope this tragedy will lead to increased awareness and improved safety on local waterways.
Final Words
As the families of Natalie Sansivero and Jerome Williams begin the painful process of mourning, the entire Western New York community stands with them in support. Their sudden and tragic loss has left a void that words cannot fill, but their memory will endure — in the hearts of those they loved, and in the lives they touched.
Funeral and memorial service details will be shared in the coming days.
Anyone wishing to provide information related to the accident or offer support to the families is encouraged to contact:
New York State Park Police — Niagara Headquarters
📞 Phone: (716) 278-1777
📍 Address: 570 Whirlpool Street, Niagara Falls, NY 14301
May Natalie and Jerome be remembered not for the way they left us, but for the kindness, joy, and light they brought into the world.